中国货币政策不确定性与新企业进入——基于随机波动率区制转换模型的货币政策不确定性测算Monetary Policy Uncertainty and New Firm Entry in China: Measuring Monetary Policy Uncertainty with the Stochastic Volatility Regime-Switch Model
黄实磊
摘要(Abstract):
货币政策不确定性代表了货币政策调整的潜在成本,本文基于广延边际效应视角,综合实物期权机制和金融摩擦机制考察货币政策不确定性对新企业进入的影响。本文基于随机波动率区制转换模型测算中国货币政策不确定性,并利用中国工业企业数据库测算城市-行业层面的新企业进入率。研究结果表明,货币政策不确定性显著降低了新企业进入率,实物期权机制和金融摩擦机制是货币政策不确定性抑制新企业进入的有效传导渠道。从实物期权机制来看,行业资产不可逆性和行业进入门槛分别加剧和减弱了货币政策不确定性的抑制作用;进一步,本文将风险感知视角引入实物期权机制,发现宏观经济环境改善能够缓解货币政策不确定性的抑制作用,感知不确定性加剧了货币政策不确定性的抑制作用。从金融摩擦机制来看,宏观信贷资源可得性和地区金融发展程度能够缓解货币政策不确定性的抑制效应;进一步,本文将企业所有制性质作为融资约束的划分依据,发现货币政策不确定性抑制新企业进入的作用对非国有企业更突出。研究结论对于理解货币政策不确定性的广延边际效应、防范化解重大风险和优化货币政策调控具有重要启示。
关键词(KeyWords): 货币政策不确定性;新企业进入;实物期权;金融摩擦;感知不确定性
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 黄实磊
参考文献(References):
- 陈建伟,苏丽锋,郭思文.2021.进口渗透、需求异质性与企业进入[J].中国工业经济,(7):175-192.Chen J W,Su L F,Guo S W.2021.Import penetration,demand heterogeneity and firm entry[J].China Industrial Economics,(7):175-192.(in Chinese) 顾海峰,于家珺.2019.中国经济政策不确定性与银行风险承担[J].世界经济,42(11):148-171.Gu H F,Yu J J.2019.China's economic policy uncertainty and bank's risk-taking[J].The Journal of World Economy,42(11):148-171.(in Chinese) 何德旭,张雪兰,王朝阳,等.2020.货币政策不确定性、银行信贷与企业资本结构动态调整[J].经济管理,42(7):5-22.He D X,Zhang X L,Wang C Y,et al.2020.Uncertainty in monetary policy,banking credit and the dynamic adjustment of enterprises' capital structure[J].Business and Management Journal,42(7):5-22.(in Chinese) 洪永淼,刘俸奇,薛涧坡.2023.政府与市场心理因素的经济影响及其测度[J].管理世界,39(3):30-51.Hong Y M,Liu F Q,Xue J P.2023.Measurement of psychological factors and their economic impact in the relationship between government and market[J].Journal of Management World,39(3):30-51.(in Chinese) 纪洋,王旭,谭语嫣,等.2018.经济政策不确定性、政府隐性担保与企业杠杆率分化[J].经济学(季刊),17(2):449-470.Ji Y,Wang X,Tan Y Y,et al.2018.Economic policy uncertainty,implicit guarantee and divergence of corporate leverage rate[J].China Economic Quarterly,17(2):449-470.(in Chinese) 李凤羽,杨墨竹.2015.经济政策不确定性会抑制企业投资吗?——基于中国经济政策不确定指数的实证研究[J].金融研究,(4):115-129.Li F Y,Yang M Z.2015.Can economic policy uncertainty influence corporate investment?The empirical research by using China economic policy uncertainty index[J].Journal of Financial Research,(4):115-129.(in Chinese) 李坤望,蒋为.2015.市场进入与经济增长——以中国制造业为例的实证分析[J].经济研究,50(5):48-60.Li K W,Jiang W.2015.Market entry and economic growth:evidence from Chinese manufacturing industry[J].Economic Research Journal,50(5):48-60.(in Chinese) 李力,黄新飞.2022.货币政策不确定性与商业银行风险承担研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,42(4):847-864.Li L,Huang X F.2022.Research on monetary policy uncertainty and commercial banks' risk-taking[J].Systems Engineering—Theory & Practice,42(4):847-864.(in Chinese) 李增福,陈俊杰,连玉君,等.2022.经济政策不确定性与企业短债长用[J].管理世界,38(1):77-89,143.Li Z F,Chen J J,Lian Y J,et al.2022.Economic policy uncertainty and corporate short-term debt for long-term use[J].Journal of Management World,38(1):77-89,143.(in Chinese) 刘贯春,张军,刘媛媛.2022.宏观经济环境、风险感知与政策不确定性[J].世界经济,45(8):30-56.Liu G C,Zhang J,Liu Y Y.2022.Macroeconomic environment,risk perception and policy uncertainty[J].The Journal of World Economy,45(8):30-56.(in Chinese) 刘慧,张勇.2022.货币政策不确定性的定义、测度及成因分析[J].经济学动态,(6):61-79.Liu H,Zhang Y.2022.Definition,measurement and cause of monetary policy uncertainty[J].Economic Perspectives,(6):61-79.(in Chinese) 谭小芬,张文婧.2017.经济政策不确定性影响企业投资的渠道分析[J].世界经济,40(12):3-26.Tan X F,Zhang W J.2017.The transmission mechanism analysis of the impact of economic policy uncertainty on corporate investment[J].The Journal of World Economy,40(12):3-26.(in Chinese) 王博,李力,郝大鹏.2019.货币政策不确定性、违约风险与宏观经济波动[J].经济研究,54(3):119-134.Wang B,Li L,Hao D P.2019.Monetary policy uncertainty,default risks and macroeconomic fluctuations[J].Economic Research Journal,54(3):119-134.(in Chinese) 王立勇,王申令.2020.货币政策不确定性研究进展[J].经济学动态,(6):109-122.Wang L Y,Wang S L.2020.Research progress on monetary policy uncertainty[J].Economic Perspectives,(6):109-122.(in Chinese) 曾松林,刘周熠,黄赛男.2022.经济政策不确定性、金融发展与双边跨境银行资本流动[J].国际金融研究,(10):61-71.Zeng S L,Liu Z Y,Huang S N.2022.Economic policy uncertainty,financial development and bilateral cross-border banking capital flows[J].Studies of International Finance,(10):61-71.(in Chinese) 张杰,庞瑞芝.2022.货币政策不确定性、纵向产业结构与杠杆率分化[J].经济学报,9(4):88-123.Zhang J,Pang R Z.2022.Monetary policy uncertainty,vertical structure of industries and divergence of leverage ratio[J].China Journal of Economics,9(4):88-123.(in Chinese) 周晔,王亚梅.2021.货币政策不确定性与商业银行流动性创造关系研究:兼论流动性创造的周期效应[J].经济学家,(9):78-88.Zhou Y,Wang Y M.2021.Research on the relationship of monetary policy uncertainty and commercial bank liquidity creation—On the periodic effect of liquidity creation[J].Economist,(9):78-88.(in Chinese) 祝梓翔,高然,邓翔.2020.内生不确定性、货币政策与中国经济波动[J].中国工业经济,(2):25-43.Zhu Z X,Gao R,Deng X.2020.Endogenous uncertainty,monetary policy and China's economic fluctuation[J].China Industrial Economics,(2):25-43.(in Chinese) Baker S R,Bloom N,Davis S J.2016.Measuring economic policy uncertainty[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,131(4):1593-1636. Beckmann J,Czudaj R L.2023.Perceived monetary policy uncertainty[J].Journal of International Money and Finance,130:102761. Brandt L,Van Biesebroeck J,Zhang Y F.2012.Creative accounting or creative destruction?Firm-level productivity growth in Chinese manufacturing[J].Journal of Development Economics,97(2):339-351. Chen K J,Ren J,Zha T.2018.The nexus of monetary policy and shadow banking in China[J].American Economic Review,108(12):3891-3936. Christiano L J,Motto R,Rostagno M.2014.Risk shocks[J].American Economic Review,104(1):27-65. Cui C T,Li L S Z.2023.Trade policy uncertainty and new firm entry:Evidence from China[J].Journal of Development Economics,163:103093. Dixit A K,Pindyck R S.1994.Investment under uncertainty[M].United Kingdom:Princeton University Press. Fasani S,Mumtaz H,Rossi L.2023.Monetary policy uncertainty and firm dynamics[J].Review of Economic Dynamics,47:278-296. Gao R,Zhu Z X,Lin J H.2022.Consumption-investment comovement and the dynamic impact of monetary policy uncertainty in China[J].Economic Modelling,113:105908. Gulen H,Ion M.2016.Policy uncertainty and corporate investment[J].The Review of Financial Studies,29(3):523-564. Hosszejni D,Kastner G.2021.Modeling univariate and multivariate stochastic volatility in R with stochvol and factorstochvol[J].Journal of Statistical Software,100(12):1-34. Huang Y,Luk P.2020.Measuring economic policy uncertainty in China[J].China Economic Review,59:101367. Husted L,Rogers J,Sun B.2020.Monetary policy uncertainty[J].Journal of Monetary Economics,115:20-36. Li L,Tang Y,Xiang J J.2020.Measuring China's monetary policy uncertainty and its impact on the real economy[J].Emerging Markets Review,44:100714.
- (1)经济金融因素包括:各省人均国内生产总值对数(2000年不变价)、居民消费价格指数、产业结构(第二产业比重和第三产业比重)、城镇化率(城镇人口比例)、金融发展程度(金融机构年末存款余额与国内生产总值比值和金融机构年末贷款余额与国内生产总值比值)、公共基础设施(公路里程与区域面积比值)、固定资产投资(全社会固定资产投资对数2000年不变价)、公共财政支出(地方财政支出与国内生产总值比重)、人均储蓄(人均城乡储蓄存款2000年不变价);社会人口因素包括:人口死亡率、老年抚养比、少儿抚养比、平均家庭人口规模、教育水平(普通高校在校学生数对数)、城镇居民基本医疗保险基金支出2000年不变价对数值。 (2)限于篇幅,稳健性检验结果未报告,备索。 (3)刘贯春等(2019)行业资产可逆性排名倒序的10个行业是畜牧业、渔业、燃气生产和供应业、纺织业、农业、卫生业、餐饮业、林业、木材加工及木、竹、藤、棕、草制品业、家具制造业,本文结果与之类似。