刘胜,温锡峰,陈秀英

• 1:广东外语外贸大学粤港澳大湾区研究院
• 2:广东外语外贸大学经济贸易学院
• 3:广东金融学院经济贸易学院

摘要(Abstract)：

循环经济政策能通过减少资源消耗浪费、实现资源循环再利用来提升企业环境绩效，但也可能会因此加剧规制成本压力或受困于技术复杂性而挫败企业治污积极性。为此，本文利用中国工业企业数据库、工业企业污染排放数据和投入产出数据，通过构建双重差分模型识别循环经济试点政策对企业污染排放的影响，以分析其到底是企业污染治理中的“助推器”还是“绊脚石”。研究发现：循环经济试点政策实施后，实验组的污染物排放量相比于对照组显著降低，说明循环经济试点政策显著提高了企业环境绩效。这一结论在采用替换被解释变量、删除同期政策干扰、控制行业时间趋势、随机抽取实验组的安慰剂等一系列稳健性检验后依然成立。进一步地，循环经济政策实施有利于促进企业节能降耗、加强末端处理和提升技术开发能力，进而推动企业环境绩效提升。异质性检验发现，循环经济政策的作用在非资源型城市的企业、超大型城市的企业以及上游服务业外资开放度高的行业的企业样本中更为突出。在“双碳”目标下，本文从循环经济的新视角拓展了环境规制政策效果评估的理论研究，并为助力实现绿色低碳循环发展、推进生态文明建设、擘画“美丽中国”蓝图提供了靶向发力的政策依据。

关键词(KeyWords)： 循环经济政策;企业污染排放;环境绩效;准自然实验;“双碳”目标

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 广东省哲学社会科学规划青年项目“数字化赋能与制造业全球价值链攀升：理论逻辑与广东实践”（GD22YYJ16）;; 广州市哲学社会科学发展“十四五”规划课题“广州建设现代服务业强市研究：基于数字化转型协同治理视角”（2022GZQN06）

作者(Author): 刘胜,温锡峰,陈秀英

DOI: 10.16513/j.cnki.cje.2023.02.004

参考文献(References)：

• 白露，白永秀，薛耀文，等.2007.循环经济实现途径研究的回顾和展望[J].湖南师范大学社会科学学报，36(1):84-88.Bai L,Bai Y X,Xue Y W,et al.2007.Summarize of the ways of realizing circular economy in developing cities[J].Journal of Social Science of Hunan Normal University,36(1):84-88.(in Chinese)
• 陈诗一.2010.节能减排与中国工业的双赢发展：2009—2049[J].经济研究，45(3):129-143.Chen S Y.2010.Energy-save and emission-abate activity with its impact on industrial win-win development in China:2009—2049[J].Economic Research Journal,45(3):129-143.(in Chinese)
• 陈诗一，陈登科.2018.雾霾污染、政府治理与经济高质量发展[J].经济研究，53(2):20-34.Chen S Y,Chen D K.2018.Air pollution,government regulations and high-quality economic development[J].Economic Research Journal,53(2):20-34.(in Chinese)
• 陈硕，陈婷.2014.空气质量与公共健康：以火电厂二氧化硫排放为例[J].经济研究，49(8):158-169.Chen S,Chen T.2014.Air pollution and public health:Evidence from sulfur dioxide emission of coal-fired power stations in China[J].Economic Research Journal,49(8):158-169.(in Chinese)
• 陈钊，陈乔伊.2019.中国企业能源利用效率：异质性、影响因素及政策含义[J].中国工业经济，(12):78-95.Chen Z,Chen Q Y.2019.Energy efficiency of Chinese firms:Heterogeneity,influencing factors and policy implications[J].China Industrial Economics,(12):78-95.(in Chinese)
• 豆建民，沈艳兵.2014.产业转移对中国中部地区的环境影响研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境，24(11):96-102.Dou J M,Shen Y B.2014.On the influence of the industrial transfer on the environment in the central region of China[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,24(11):96-102.(in Chinese)
• 高翔，何欢浪.2021.清洁生产、绿色转型与企业产品质量升级[J].统计研究，38(7):64-75.Gao X,He H L.2021.Clean production,green transformation and enterprise product quality upgrading[J].Statistical Research,38(7):64-75.(in Chinese)
• 韩超，张伟广，冯展斌.2017.环境规制如何“去”资源错配——基于中国首次约束性污染控制的分析[J].中国工业经济(4):115-134.Han C,Zhang W G,Feng Z B.2017.How does environmental regulation remove resource misallocation—An analysis of the first obligatory pollution control in China[J].China Industrial Economics,(4):115-134.(in Chinese)
• 韩超，陈震，王震.2020.节能目标约束下企业污染减排效应的机制研究[J].中国工业经济，(10):43-61.Han C,Chen Z,Wang Z.2020.Study on the mechanism of Firms' pollution reduction under the constraint of energy-saving target[J].China Industrial Economics,(10):43-61.(in Chinese)
• 韩超，王震，田蕾.2021.环境规制驱动减排的机制：污染处理行为与资源再配置效应[J].世界经济，44(8):82-105.Han C,Wang Z,Tian L.2021.The mechanism of environmental regulation driving emission reduction:Pollution treatment behavior and resource reallocation effect[J].The Journal of World Economy,44(8):82-105.(in Chinese)
• 胡志强，苗长虹.2018.中国污染产业转移的时空格局及其与污染转移的关系[J].软科学，32(7):39-43.Hu Z Q,Miao C H.2018.The spatiotemporal pattern of China's pollution industry transfer and its relationship with pollution transfer[J].Soft Science,32(7):39-43.(in Chinese)
• 黄磊，吴传清.2021.外商投资、环境规制与长江经济带城市绿色发展效率[J].改革，(3):94-110.Huang L,Wu C Q.2021.Foreign investment,environmental regulation and green development efficiency of cities along the Yangtze River economic belt[J].Reform,(3):94-110.(in Chinese)
• 李婉红，刘芳，刘天森.2022.国家高新区提升了城市创新效率吗?——基于空间集聚调节效应的实证检验[J].管理评论，34(5):93-108.Li W H,Liu F,Liu T S.2022.Can national high-tech zones improve the urban innovation efficiency?—An empirical test based on the effect of spatial agglomeration regulation[J].Management Review,34(5):93-108.(in Chinese)
• 林伯强，杜克锐.2013.要素市场扭曲对能源效率的影响[J].经济研究，48(9):125-136.Lin B Q,Du K R.2013.The energy effect of factor market distortion in China[J].Economic Research Journal,48(9):125-136.(in Chinese)
• 齐绍洲，林屾，崔静波.2018.环境权益交易市场能否诱发绿色创新?——基于我国上市公司绿色专利数据的证据[J].经济研究，53(12):129-143.Qi S Z,Lin S,Cui J B.2018.Do environmental rights trading schemes induce green innovation?Evidence from listed firms in China[J].Economic Research Journal,53(12):129-143.(in Chinese)
• 任胜钢，郑晶晶，刘东华，等.2019.排污权交易机制是否提高了企业全要素生产率——来自中国上市公司的证据[J].中国工业经济(5):5-23.Ren S G,Zheng J J,Liu D H,et al.2019.Does emissions trading system improve Firm's total factor productivity—Evidence from Chinese listed companies[J].China Industrial Economics,(5):5-23.(in Chinese)
• 邵朝对，苏丹妮，杨琦.2021.外资进入对东道国本土企业的环境效应：来自中国的证据[J].世界经济，44(3):32-60.Shao C D,Su D N,Yang Q.2021.Environmental effects of FDI on domestic firms in host countries:Evidence from China[J].The Journal of World Economy,44(3):32-60.(in Chinese)
• 苏丹妮，盛斌.2021.服务业外资开放如何影响企业环境绩效——来自中国的经验[J].中国工业经济(6):61-79.Su D N,Sheng B.2021.How services FDI opening affects firm environmental performance—Evidence from China[J].China Industrial Economics,(6):61-79.(in Chinese)
• 孙博文.2021.清洁生产标准实施对污染行业僵尸企业的处置效果[J].中国人口·资源与环境，31(11):48-58.Sun B W.2021.Estimation of the effect of the implementation of cleaner production standards on zombie firm disposal in polluting industries[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,31(11):48-58.(in Chinese)
• 唐晓华，王广凤，马小平.2007.基于生态效益的生态产业链形成研究[J].中国工业经济，(11):121-127.Tang X H,Wang G F,Ma X P.2007.Study on establishment of eco-industrial chain based on eco-efficiency[J].China Industrial Economy,(11):121-127.(in Chinese)
• 涂正革，谌仁俊.2015.排污权交易机制在中国能否实现波特效应?[J].经济研究，50(7):160-173.Tu Z G,Shen R J.2015.Can emissions trading scheme achieve the porter effect in China?[J].Economic Research Journal,50(7):160-173.(in Chinese)
• 万攀兵，杨冕，陈林.2021.环境技术标准何以影响中国制造业绿色转型——基于技术改造的视角[J].中国工业经济，(9):118-136.Wan P B,Yang M,Chen L.2021.How do environmental technology standards affect the green transition of China's manufacturing industry—A perspective from technological transformation[J].China Industrial Economics,(9):118-136.(in Chinese)
• 王军洋.2015.政府行为选择与市场逆淘汰——为什么欠发达地区更会出现污染聚集现象?[J].人文杂志，(11):102-110.Wang J Y.2015.Government behavior selection and market reverse elimination:Why is pollution aggregation more common in underdeveloped regions?[J].The Journal of Humanities,(11):102-110.(in Chinese)
• 郗永勤，赵宏伟.2010.中国循环经济政策的动因、演进、特点与评价[J].中国行政管理，(10):44-47.Xi Y Q,Zhao H W.2010.The motivation,evolution,characteristics and evaluation of circular economy in China[J].Chinese Public Administration,(10):44-47.(in Chinese)
• 谢海燕.2020.绿色发展下循环经济的现状及方向[J].宏观经济管理，(1):14-21.Xie H Y.2020.The current situation and direction of circular economy in the context of green development[J].Macroeconomic Management,(1):14-21.(in Chinese)
• 徐佳，崔静波.2020.低碳城市和企业绿色技术创新[J].中国工业经济，(12):178-196.Xu J,Cui J B.2020.Low-carbon cities and Firms' green technological innovation[J].China Industrial Economics,(12):178-196.(in Chinese)
• 张彩云，吕越.2018.绿色生产规制与企业研发创新——影响及机制研究[J].经济管理，40(1):71-91.Zhang C Y,Lv Y.2018.Green production regulation and enterprise R&D innovation:Impact and mechanism research[J].Economic Management Journal,40(1):71-91.(in Chinese)
• 张晓.1999.中国环境政策的总体评价[J].中国社会科学，(3):88-99.Zhang X.1999.The overall evaluation of China's environmental policy[J].Social Sciences in China,(3):88-99.(in Chinese)
• 张晓华，刘滨.2005.“扩大生产者责任”原则及其在循环经济发展中的作用[J].中国人口·资源与环境，15(2):19-22.Zhang X H,Liu B.2005.Extended producer responsibility and its role in the development of circular economy[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,15(2):19-22.(in Chinese)
• 张旭东，雷娟.2012.循环经济模式下生产者延伸责任研究[J].环境保护，(12):41-44.Zhang X D,Lei J.2012.Research on extended responsibility of producers under circular economy model[J].Environmental Protection,(12):41-44.(in Chinese)
• 邹松涛.2009.基于循环经济的电子废物循环利用研究[J].企业经济，(6):42-44.Zou S T.2009.Research on recycling of electronic waste based on recycling economy[J].Enterprise Economics,(6):42-44.(in Chinese)
• Beck T,Levine R,Levkov A.2010.Big bad banks?The winners and losers from bank deregulation in the United States[J].The Journal of Finance,65(5):1637-1667.
• Bongers A,Casas P.2022.The circular economy and the optimal recycling rate:A macroeconomic approach[J].Ecological Economics,199:107504.
• Busu M,Trica C L.2019.Sustainability of circular economy indicators and their impact on economic growth of the European Union[J].Sustainability,11(19):5481.
• Cainelli G,D'Amato A,Mazzanti M.2020.Resource efficient eco-innovations for a circular economy:Evidence from EU firms[J].Research Policy,49(1):103827.
• Dean T J,Brown R L,Stango V.2000.Environmental regulation as a barrier to the formation of small manufacturing establishments:A longitudinal examination[J].Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,40(1):56-75.
• Dong L,Liu Z W,Bian Y L.2021.Match circular economy and urban sustainability:Re-investigating circular economy under sustainable development goals (SDGs)[J].Circular Economy and Sustainability,1(1):243-256.
• Fan Y P,Fang C L.2020.Circular economy development in China-current situation,evaluation and policy implications[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,84:106441.
• Favot M,Massarutto A.2019.Rare-earth elements in the circular economy:The case of yttrium[J].Journal of Environmental Management,240:504-510.
• Fitch-Roy O,Benson D,Monciardini D.2020.Going around in circles?Conceptual recycling,patching and policy layering in the EU circular economy package[J].Environmental Politics,29(6):983-1003.
• Golub J.1996.State power and institutional influence in European integration:Lessons from the packaging waste directive[J].Journal of Common Market Studies,34(3):313-339.
• Halkos G,Petrou K N.2019.Analysing the energy efficiency of EU member states:The potential of energy recovery from waste in the circular economy[J].Energies,12(19):3718.
• Hoffmann V H.2007.EU ETS and investment decisions:The case of the German electricity industry[J].European Management Journal,25(6):464-474.
• Korhonen J,Honkasalo A,Sepp?l? J.2018.Circular economy:The concept and its limitations[J].Ecological Economics,143:37-46.
• Kunz N,Mayers K,Van Wassenhove L N.2018.Stakeholder views on extended producer responsibility and the circular economy[J].California Management Review,60(3):45-70.
• Lieder M,Rashid A.2016.Towards circular economy implementation:A comprehensive review in context of manufacturing industry[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,115:36-51.
• Malinauskaite J,Jouhara H,Czajczyńska D,et al.2017.Municipal solid waste management and waste-to-energy in the context of a circular economy and energy recycling in Europe[J].Energy,141:2013-2044.
• Moraga G,Huysveld S,Mathieux F,et al.2019.Circular economy indicators:What do they measure?[J].Resources,Conservation and Recycling,146:452-461.
• Morseletto P.2020.Targets for a circular economy[J].Resources,Conservation and Recycling,153:104553.
• Mossali E,Picone N,Gentilini L,et al.2020.Lithium-ion batteries towards circular economy:A literature review of opportunities and issues of recycling treatments[J].Journal of Environmental Management,264:110500.
• Porter M E,Van der Linde C.1995.Toward a new conception of the environment-competitiveness relationship[J].Journal of Economic Perspectives,9(4):97-118.
• Reichel A,Schoenmakere M D,Gillabel J,et al.Circular economy in Europe:Developing the knowledge base[R].The European Environment Agency,2016.
• Scheinberg A,Nesi■,et al.2016.From collision to collaboration-Integrating informal recyclers and re-use operators in Europe:A review[J].Waste Management & Research:The Journal for a Sustainable Circular Economy,34(9):820-839.
• Su B W,Heshmati A,Geng Y,et al.2013.A review of the circular economy in China:Moving from rhetoric to implementation[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,42:215-227.
• Tsiliyannis C A.2019.The Cycle rate as the means for real-time monitoring of wastes in circular economy[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,227:911-931.
• Zhu J M,Fan C M,Shi H J,et al.2019.Efforts for a circular economy in China:A comprehensive review of policies[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology,23(1):110-118.
• (1)考虑到通知中仅将重庆市(三峡库区)作为试点区域,即仅对部分地区而非全市实行循环经济试点政策,因此在检验时将重庆市剔除。在此基础上,本文实证所采用的第一次循环经济试点地区共涉及50个城市。
• (2)受到数据可得性等因素的影响,本文在实际回归时未能涵盖西藏自治区的企业样本。
• (3)根据《全国资源型城市可持续发展规划(2013—2020)》和国家统计局关于地区的划分,本文将资源型城市(按地理行政区划)对应划入到东、中、西和东北地区。
• (4)人口规模处于50万以下为小城市,处于50万到100万的为中等城市,处于100万到500万的为大城市,处于500万到1000万的为特大城市,超过1000万的为超大城市。由于后两者的数量并不多,因此本文将其归为一类,并将其界定为超大型城市(super),以与该通知中的“超大城市”区分开来。
• (5)《国家酸雨和二氧化硫污染防治“十一五”规划》所指定的重点监测行业包括电力、化工、石化、钢铁、有色、医药、造纸、冶金、水泥和玻璃等行业。
• (6)中国循环经济协会官网:https://www.chinacace.org/news/view?id=6420