关于中国股票市场模糊性、风险与风险资产收益率的实证研究An Empirical Study on the Ambiguity, Risk and Excess Return of China’s Stock Market
刘语,王一迪,张丽宏
摘要(Abstract)：
我们采用Brenner and Izhakian(2018)基于期望效用模型(EUUP)构建的实证模糊性指标,分析了上证综指代表的中国股票市场中风险、模糊性和股市收益率的关系。研究发现,基于月度数据,模糊性在中国股市中被定价,并且其对于风险资产收益率的解释效果远优于风险。市场模糊性溢价水平和市场有利概率有密切关系,实证结果和已有行为研究的发现以及理论预期相符。中国股市的有利概率临界概率点约为45%,略低于美国股市,表明中国投资者对模糊性更加担忧,要求的模糊性溢价更高。依据对实证数据的进一步分析,我们发现EUUP构建的模糊性测度面临两个潜在问题,并对其进行了讨论和提出了建议。同时发现本文模糊性指标和中国经济政策不确定性指标存在正相关关系,但与具体政策领域的不确定性指标不具有相关关系。
关键词(KeyWords)： 模糊性;风险;中国股票市场;有利收益概率
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 刘语,王一迪,张丽宏
DOI: 10.16513/j.cnki.cje.20200927.002
参考文献(References)：
- 靳光辉,刘志远,花贵如.2016.政策不确定性、投资者情绪与企业投资——基于战略性新兴产业的实证研究[J].中央财经大学学报,(5):60-69.Jin G H,Liu Z Y,Hua G R.2016.Policy uncertainty,investor sentiment and corporate investment:An empirical study on strategic and emerging industry[J].Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics,(5):60-69.(in Chinese)
- 唐朝.2017.经济政策不确定性与金融市场参与——基于基金流量的经验证据[J].投资研究,(11):76-93.Tang C.2017.Economic policy uncertainty and financial market participation——Empirical evidence from mutual fund flow data[J].Review of Investment Studies,(11):76-93.(in Chinese)
- 王中兴,卢余刚.2019.基于模糊熵和模糊夏普比率的多阶段投资组合模型及实证[J].广西大学学报,(6):1814-1821.Wang Z X,Lu Y G.2019.Empirical analysis on multi-period portfolio model based on fuzzy entropy and fuzzy Sharpe ratio[J].Journal of Guangxi University (Natural Science Edition),(6):1814-1821.(in Chinese)
- Andersen T G,Bollerslev T,Diebold F X,et al.2001.The distribution of realized stock return volatility[J].Journal of Financial Economics,61(1):43-76.
- Andreou P C,Kagkadis A,Maio P F,et al.2019.Dispersion in options investors’ versus analysts’ expectations:Predictive inference for stock returns[EB/OL].https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2379606.
- Baker S R,Bloom N,Davis S J.2016.Measuring economic policy uncertainty[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,131(4):1593-1636.
- Barron O E,Stanford M H,Yu Y.2009.Further evidence on the relation between analysts’ forecast dispersion and stock returns[J].Contemporary Accounting Research,26(2):329-357.
- Black F.1976.Studies of stock market volatility changes[C]//Proceedings of the American Statistical Association,Business and Economic Statistics Section.Washington DC:American Statistical Association,177-181.
- Brenner M,Izhakian Y.2018.Asset pricing and ambiguity:Empirical evidence[J].Journal of Financial Economics,130(3):503-531.
- Campbell J Y.1987.Stock returns and the term structure[J].Journal of Financial Economics,18(2):373-399.
- Campbell J Y,Hentschel L.1992.No news is good news:An asymmetric model of changing volatility in stock returns[J].Journal of Financial Economics,31(3):281-318.
- Cao H H,Wang T,Zhang H H.2005.Model uncertainty,limited market participation,and asset prices[J].The Review of Financial Studies,18(4):1219-1251.
- Davis S J,Liu D Q,Sheng X G.2019.Economic policy uncertainty in China since 1949:The view from mainland newspaper[EB/OL].https://www.frbatlanta.org/-/media/documents/news/conferences/2019/0919-workshop-on-chinas-economy/presen tations/davis.pdf.
- Driouchi T,Trigeorgis L,So R H Y.2018.Option implied ambiguity and its information content:Evidence from the subprime crisis[J].Annals of Operations Research,262(2):463-491.
- French K R,Schwert G W,Stambaugh R F.1987.Expected stock returns and volatility[J].Journal of Financial Economics,19(1):3-29.
- Garlappi L,Uppal R,Wang T.2007.Portfolio selection with parameter and model uncertainty:A multi-prior approach[J].The Review of Financial Studies,20(1):41-81.
- Ghysels E,Santa-Clara P,Valkanov R.2005.There is a risk-return trade-off after all[J].Journal of Financial Economics,76(3):509-548.
- Glosten L R ,Jagannathan R ,Runkle D E .1993.On the relation between the expected value and the volatility of the nominal excess return on stocks[J].The Journal of Finance,48(5):1779-1801.
- Guo H,Whitelaw R F.2006.Uncovering the risk-return relation in the stock market[J].The Journal of Finance,61(3):1433-1463.
- Harvey C R.2001.The specification of conditional expectations[J].Journal of Empirical Finance,8(5):573-637.
- Huang Y,Paul L.2020.Measuring economic policy uncertainty in China[J].China Economic Review,59(C).
- Izhakian Y.2017.Expected utility with uncertain probabilities theory[J].Journal of Mathematical Economics,69:91-103.
- Kendall M G,Stuart A.2010.The advanced theory of statistics.vol.1:Distribution theory[M].London:Wiley.
- Knight F H.1921.Risk,uncertainty and profit[M].Boston:Houghton Mifflin.
- Liang C Y C,Tang Z Y.2018.Idiosyncratic Return Volatility,Uncertainty,and Asset Pricing Implications[M/OL].https://ssrn.com/abstract=3019379.
- Liang C Y C,Tang Z Y,Xu X W.2019.Uncertainty,momentum,and profitability[J].The Journal of Portfolio Management,45(4):91-104.
- Merton R C.1980.On estimating the expected return on the market:An exploratory investigation[J].Journal of Financial Economics,8(4):323-361.
- So R H Y,Driouchi T,Trigeorgis L.2016.Option market ambiguity,excess returns and the equity premium[EB/OL].https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID2830520_code2429332.pdf?abstractid=2663317&mirid=1.
- Ulrich M.2013.Inflation ambiguity and the term structure of U.S.government bonds[J].Journal of Monetary Economics,60(2):295-309.
- Williams C D.2015.Asymmetric responses to earnings news:A case for ambiguity[J].The Accounting Review,90(2):785-817.